We hot-fill and pH test every bottle we make, and we want every order to show up in perfect shape. Because our sauces are food products, we handle returns a little differently than most stores. Here’s how it works.
Damaged, Leaking, or Wrong Items
If a bottle arrives broken or leaking, or we sent you the wrong sauce, we’ll make it right with a free replacement or a full refund for that item, your choice.
Just email orders@lufkinpepperco.com within 7 days of delivery with:
- Your order number
- A photo of the damaged or incorrect item and the packaging
You don’t need to send anything back.
Returns
For food safety reasons, we can’t accept returns of hot sauce once it has left our hands, opened or unopened. If something isn’t right with your order, please reach out anyway. We’re a small business and we’ll do our best to take care of you.
Canceling an Order
Need to change or cancel? Email us as soon as possible. If your order hasn’t shipped yet, we’ll cancel it and issue a full refund. Once an order has shipped, it can’t be canceled.
Lost Packages
If your tracking hasn’t updated in several days or your package shows delivered but you can’t find it, email us and we’ll work with the carrier to track it down. Please double-check that your shipping address is correct at checkout. We can’t be responsible for orders shipped to an address entered incorrectly.
Local Pickup Orders
Please check your bottles when you pick them up. If anything is wrong, let us know right then and we’ll swap it on the spot.
How Refunds Are Issued
Approved refunds go back to your original payment method. We process them within 3 business days of approval. Depending on your bank or card issuer, it may take another 5–10 business days to show up on your statement.
Questions?
Email orders@lufkinpepperco.com or use our contact form. We read every message.

